PDA

View Full Version : Leave diagnosis of AT rupture to the experts



JasonC
03-01-2007, 02:34 PM
12 weeks ago I was playing indoor soccer when, snap, crash, ouch! Yes, if you're reading this you've probably been there. After the adreneline kicked in I was able to drive home and also managed to hobble into work the next day. At this point I should've seeked professional help, but foolishly self-diagnosed a tear of the AT (As a PE teacher I have some knowledge of sports injuries). After 48 hrs of RICE, and having borrowed some crutches, the pain and tenderness was still the same. This is when I went to see my 'trusty' sports/clinical masseur, who in the past has got me back on the playing field after suffering lesser injuries. His diagnosis was similar to mine, grade 2 tear to the AT and he began a program of massage and manipulation of the injured area (why he didn't feel the hollow dip in the back of the heel I'll never know- all very good in hindsight). After about 2 weeks it felt like it was getting better and as I was walking up some stairs, POW! I felt even more pain than I had during the initial injury. Back to my man the next day who explained to me that it was a setback that required more intensive work. Still no referral! Are you getting the picture here? Anyway, after 6 weeks of limping and minimal improvement, by pure luck I saw a doctor friend. He referred me to a surgeon and the rest is history. Because I waited 6 weeks the chance of rerupture is about 20%. I have just come out of my third cast (over a 7 week period) and am now walking gingerly with some support from my crutches.
I informed my (ex) masseur about my surgery and he was most surprised. I would have thought a trained sports masseur would be able to recognise an injury such as a complete ATR compared to a tear. Was he motivated by money? Well his treatment all up cost me about $400 Aussie dollars. So I think not. Should I bother suing? I've thought about it.
Will I play soccer again? I don't think so, my wife would kill me if she had to put up with 3 children again! A painful lesson learned by me. Unlike the vast majority of similar cases I have read on this site, who have sensibly seeked professional help early, I chose to use my limited knowledge of sports science and trust someone who was obviously not qualified to pass judgement.

Sydney Uni Sports Doc
03-01-2007, 05:26 PM
A very interesting and hard question. I think not if your injury run continues. The only advice I can give is: Be careful.

kjwilkin
05-01-2007, 08:23 PM
12 weeks ago I was playing indoor soccer when, snap, crash, ouch! Yes, if you're reading this you've probably been there. After the adreneline kicked in I was able to drive home and also managed to hobble into work the next day. At this point I should've seeked professional help, but foolishly self-diagnosed a tear of the AT (As a PE teacher I have some knowledge of sports injuries). After 48 hrs of RICE, and having borrowed some crutches, the pain and tenderness was still the same. This is when I went to see my 'trusty' sports/clinical masseur, who in the past has got me back on the playing field after suffering lesser injuries. His diagnosis was similar to mine, grade 2 tear to the AT and he began a program of massage and manipulation of the injured area (why he didn't feel the hollow dip in the back of the heel I'll never know- all very good in hindsight). After about 2 weeks it felt like it was getting better and as I was walking up some stairs, POW! I felt even more pain than I had during the initial injury. Back to my man the next day who explained to me that it was a setback that required more intensive work. Still no referral! Are you getting the picture here? Anyway, after 6 weeks of limping and minimal improvement, by pure luck I saw a doctor friend. He referred me to a surgeon and the rest is history. Because I waited 6 weeks the chance of rerupture is about 20%. I have just come out of my third cast (over a 7 week period) and am now walking gingerly with some support from my crutches.
I informed my (ex) masseur about my surgery and he was most surprised. I would have thought a trained sports masseur would be able to recognise an injury such as a complete ATR compared to a tear. Was he motivated by money? Well his treatment all up cost me about $400 Aussie dollars. So I think not. Should I bother suing? I've thought about it.
Will I play soccer again? I don't think so, my wife would kill me if she had to put up with 3 children again! A painful lesson learned by me. Unlike the vast majority of similar cases I have read on this site, who have sensibly seeked professional help early, I chose to use my limited knowledge of sports science and trust someone who was obviously not qualified to pass judgement.


Hi there,

Never give up of living your dream of playing soccer again !!!

I have had 6 knee operations and one of my former GPs told me that I'd probably never walk again. Well, I'm walking extremely well now and keeping active by going to the gym and doing pilates. About 6 weeks ago I had surgery for medial patella dislocations. After 3 days I was walking without crutches. My knee surgeon has always believed in me and never told me "never".

My sport was hockey and am determined to go back to it.

Like you I have been cursed with injury. Last year I had an ankle and peroneal reconstruction followed by 2 knee operations. I am due to undergo shoulder surgery in the next couple of months. However, I have never given up and my dream is to run again.

When I was recovering from a major knee operation I saw a movie called "Never tell me never". It really spurred me on to never say "never"as you really don't know what will happen.

Good luck and let us know how you go !!