PDA

View Full Version : Razorbacks using medical report to sack player



injuryupdate
08-07-2005, 08:34 PM
According to the Daily Telegraph yesterday, the West Sydney Razorbacks are trying to cut short Simon Dwight's contract because of a medical assessment of his knee problems. The report may not be accurate as there were no quotes from the club medical staff. However, the use of medical reports to terminate a contract early would be very controversial. Not wanting to commend this report by any means, but out of interest, here it is:

Row looms over Dwight contract
By Tim Morrissey
July 7, 2005

WEST Sydney Razorbacks have written to seven-year star Simon Dwight urging him to retire - but deny they will sack him.

West Sydney chief executive Robbie Cadee confirmed the club had sent the letter to Dwight, but denied it was basically a notice of termination.

Dwight has been plagued by knee injuries and it has restricted his ability to train with teammates in the lead-up to games.

"Simon's got to decide what he's doing, whether he's going to be retiring or not," Cadee said. "We've been told by our medical staff that his knees are shot and that he's got to consider retiring because they just can't treat him any more and they are worried about long-term damage."

However, Dwight was still a force in the NBL last season, averaging 16 points and 11 rebounds a game for West Sydney - which is above his career figures over 314 games of 14.9 points per game and 8.5 rebounds per game.

Dwight has approached and secured the full support of the NBL Players Association, which is affiliated with the Media Entertainment and Arts Alliance union.

MEAA representative Peter Moscat yesterday told The Daily Telegraph the matter was now in the hands of the lawyers.

"Without going into Simon's contract our legal people think he's got a very, very strong case and we are willing to back him all the way," Moscat said. "As far as we are concerned there is a contract there to be honoured.

"This has got to stop in basketball. You just can't cut players willy-nilly."

Cadee said he was unsure how Dwight's retirement for medical reasons would leave the club's contractual obligations but he was adamant Dwight had not been cut.
"The last thing I said to Simon is, 'Mate, you've got a contract but I don't know whether it will stand if you retire. But you need to go away and obviously think about it'."

Moscat and the MEAA's legal representatives will sit down with Cadee on Monday to discuss Dwight's position.

The Daily Telegraph

injuryupdate
22-08-2005, 11:24 AM
Looks like the dispute has been settled amicably. You sense they have paid out a portion of his contract and both parties are happy.

From AAP/Foxsports:

'Landlord' forced to retire
August 22, 2005

WEST Sydney Razorbacks forward Simon Dwight, the National Basketball League's all-time leading shot-blocker, has retired.

Dwight, 29, nicknamed as the "Landlord" by the fans, has been unable to train in the lead-up to the new NBL season, starting on September 2, and has been told he could sustain permanent and debilitating knee problems if he continues to play.

"Injury forced me to stop playing, and it's for the sake of my long-term health that I have had to give the game away," the former Australian Boomer said today.

"Retirement however will have an upside, I'll get to be with my family more, our son William is just 16 months old, so that is a special time and I'll be there to see him develop and grow."

Dwight played 314 games over 10 years in the NBL, including two Grand Finals with the Razorbacks in 2002 and 2004.

In November 2002 Dwight etched his name in basketball history as the all time best-shot blocker when he passed the James Crawford-held record of 788. Last season, he went on to become the first player in NBL history to achieve the landmark of 1000 blocked shots. He finished with 1050, while averaging 14.9 points-per-game, and 8.5 rebounds.

He won a world championship as part of Australia's under 22 team in 1997, and claimed a silver medal with under 19s in 1995.

In 1998 he made his debut for the Boomers, representing Australia at the world championships.

Dwight soldiered on with the knee injuries last season managing to play in all but two games for the Razorbacks.

"My fondest memories will be mostly of the people that I've played with since I was a young bloke," he said.
"Guys like Scott McGregor and Sam Mackinnon who I've known for so long.

"Ending my career playing with those blokes, whose friendship I have valued, was a privilege.

"So too was being able to play eight years as a Razorback, and playing in two Grand Finals will always stand out when I look back.

Known to fans as the "Landlord", Dwight took just 238 games to pass Crawford's shot-blocking record, one the former Perth Wildcat needed 503 games to set between 1982 and 1999.

Dwight debuted in the league in 1995 for the Canberra Cannons, before moving to the Razorbacks as a foundation player in 1998.

Before his retirement, he was the sole remaining foundation player with the club.

Razorbacks chief executive Robbie Cadee said: "Simon has had a marvellous career in the NBL and with the Razorbacks.

"He helped start up and build this club. He has been with us since day one and leaves massive shoes to fill. We are very sad to lose him."